A former US marine who restrained a mentally ailing homeless man to defend passengers on a commuter practice in New York Metropolis in 2023 has been discovered not responsible of criminally negligent murder by a Manhattan jury. Prosecutors had charged Daniel Penny with killing Jordan Neely and argued he was motivated by racism.
Penny was on a practice in Might 2023 when Neely entered the automotive and began shouting that “somebody goes to die in the present day.” With two of his pals, the ex-marine restrained Neely and known as police and an ambulance. Neely later died in a hospital, and the native authorities pressed costs in opposition to Penny.
On Monday, the Manhattan jury discovered Penny not responsible of criminally negligent murder. Choose Maxwell Wiley had already thrown out the first cost of second-degree manslaughter on Friday, when the jurors couldn’t agree on a verdict.
“Who would you like on the following practice experience with you?” considered one of Penny’s attorneys, Steven Raiser, stated in his closing arguments final week. “The man with the earbuds minding his personal enterprise who could be there for you if one thing occurred? Or maybe you simply hope that somebody like Jordan Neely doesn’t enter that practice if you end up on their lonesome, on their lonesome in a crowd of others frozen with concern?”
“What’s so tragic about this case is that although the defendant began out attempting to do the correct factor, because the chokehold progressed, the defendant knew that Jordan Neely was in nice misery and dying, and he needlessly continued,” prosecutor Dafna Yoran stated in her closing assertion.
Yoran and her workforce had referred to Penny as “the white man” all through the trial, giving the affair a racial dimension. Two of Penny’s black pals, who had helped him subdue Neely, weren’t charged.
The case polarized each New York and the US, with one aspect arguing that Penny was a racist assassin and Neely was a mentally ailing man failed by the town and the state, whereas the opposite held up the previous Marine as a hero who deserved a medal and never an indictment.
Mayor Eric Adams, a Democrat and black himself, stated earlier this month that Penny did “what we must always have achieved as a metropolis” by defending others.
The trial heard from over 40 witnesses, from passengers who had been within the automotive with Penny and Neely that day to medical specialists. The town’s medical expert, Dr. Cynthia Harris, dominated that Neely’s demise had been a murder brought on by Penny’s chokehold based mostly on watching a six-minute video recorded by one of many witnesses.
The protection’s medical professional, Dr. Satish Chundru, claimed that Neely died from “the mixed results of sickle cell disaster, the schizophrenia, the battle and restraint, and the artificial marijuana.” A toxicology report confirmed the presence of the drug K2 in Neely’s system.
Talking with the police after the incident, Penny stated he was “not attempting to kill the man,” however “simply attempting to maintain him from hurting anyone else.”
Police had beforehand famous Neely as an “emotionally disturbed individual” who had been detained or arrested over two dozen occasions, however he was by no means checked right into a psychological establishment.
You’ll be able to share this story on social media:
